How to Play Erstwhile
Read the first clue, spend your ten chips, and know what to look at when the results come in.
Read the opening board
Every daily puzzle starts at the end of a hidden year between 2005 and 2020. The headline helps you place the story in time. The percentage next to each choice tells you what it did in the year before the puzzle starts. Your score comes from the five years that follow.
Place your ten chips
Each chip is worth $1,000 at the start. Spread all ten across the available choices, with up to four on any one. Select Lock in once every chip is placed.
Cash is one of the options. It earns nothing in the game and keeps its dollar value, so putting chips in cash changes how much of your result follows the other assets.
Worked example
Say you put four chips in one choice, three in a second choice and three in cash. The returns below are fictional figures to show the arithmetic.
| Choice | Start | After two years | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Choice A | $4,000 | +20% | $4,800 |
| Choice B | $3,000 | −10% | $2,700 |
| Cash | $3,000 | 0% | $3,000 |
| Portfolio | $10,000 | +5% | $10,500 |
If you rebalance at this checkpoint, the game splits that new $10,500 balance into ten chips worth $1,050 each.
Hold or rebalance
At the end of year two and again at year four, you see the updated values and another headline. Hold keeps the current positions. Rebalance gives you ten chips based on your new balance, which you can distribute again.
Look at the dollar value of each position before choosing. A holding that grew faster can now be a larger slice of the portfolio than the chip count you started with.
Read the result
At year five the game reveals the dates, your ending balance, and what the S&P 500 benchmark did during the same period. A portfolio can finish above $10,000 and still trail the benchmark. Open The backstory on the result screen to see what moved the biggest winners and losers.
Daily puzzle and archive
When is the next daily puzzle?
The original game resets at midnight in your local time.
Can I play older puzzles?
Yesterday’s puzzle is free in the official archive. The full archive and Unlimited mode are supporter features. See the original FAQ for current details.
Where do the prices come from?
The developer lists its historical price sources in the official rules. The game uses fictional money and historical outcomes.